The Confederacy on Trial: The Piracy and Sequestration Cases of 1861University Press of Kansas, 2005 - 219 страници In the annals of Civil War history, one overarching dispute remains unsettled: was the United States waging war against another nation or putting down an internal rebellion? In October 1861 three legal battles put this question to the test. As Mark Weitz reveals, these proceedings were instrumental in debating and ultimately shaping the Confederacy's very identity. Weitz takes readers to courtrooms in Philadelphia and New York, where Confederate sailors caught raiding Union vessels were tried for the capital crime of piracy. Their defense argued that they were not pirates at all but privateers acting on behalf of a sovereign nation, and thus were entitled to protection under international laws governing prisoners of war and could not be executed. Meanwhile, in South Carolina, a number of Charleston lawyers challenged the Confederacy's Sequestration Act. This law authorized government seizure of the property of "enemy aliens"—an action viewed by Southerners as a threat to civil liberties and states' rights by a central government that had assumed excessive powers. By attempting to preserve long-standing Southern traditions regarding private property and due process, the lawyers highlighted the conflict between the kind of nation the Confederacy wanted to become and the nation it was compelled to be in wartime. Weitz masterfully interweaves these stories, highlighting the extraordinary tensions between legal professionalism and the public clamor for patriotism. He shows that while the Confederacy struggled to balance its commitment to civil rights and state sovereignty with the need to wage war, the United States walked an equally fine line between officially sanctioning the new Confederacy and utilizing war powers normally directed at enemy nations. Ultimately, both sides discovered that war created irreconcilable contradictions that could not be easily resolved. The Confederacy on Trial provides an unprecedented look at the difficulty of discerning whether a conflict is a rebellion or a war between nations while it remains undecided. Addressing crucial questions regarding civil liberties, sovereignty, and national identity, the book sheds important light on the modern-day problem of waging war and balancing constitutional protections. |
Съдържание
Ye Vikings of the South | 17 |
If They Meet It Is Only to Combat | 36 |
We Shall Have No More Peace Forever | 58 |
A Fair and Impartial Trial | 71 |
Summon the Community by Sound of Trumpet | 95 |
For Gods Sake Leave This to the Clash of Arms | 163 |
Relevant Cases | 205 |
Други издания - Преглед на всички
The Confederacy on Trial: The Piracy and Sequestration Cases of 1861 Mark A. Weitz Ограничен достъп - 2005 |
Често срещани думи и фрази
alien enemy property American argued argument Ashton attorney authority became belligerent blockade Brady Cadwalader captain captured Charleston civil claim clients conceded Confed Confeder Confederacy Confederate citizens Confederate Congress Confederate Constitution Confederate government Confederate privateers Confederate Sequestration confiscation Coxetter debts defense's district court Enchantress ernment Evarts evidence existence facto federacy federal Garrick Grier Harrison Hayne high seas indictment insisted international law issue Jeff Davis Jefferson Davis Judge juror jury Justice Kelley Larocque lawyers letters of marque Lincoln Magrath McGrady ment Miles Mitchell nation Nelson North Northern opinion person Petigru Philadelphia piracy pirates prisoners prize crew prosecution question rebellion recognition recognized Savannah secession seize seizure Sequestration Act sequestration law ship Shipman South Carolina Southern sovereign status stood Sullivan tion took treason trial U.S. Congress U.S. Constitution U.S. district U.S. government U.S. Supreme Court Union United verdict vessel Whaley Wharton William Smith writ of garnishment York